A short menu earns more because every dish you drop is stock you don't buy, waste you don't throw away and kitchen time you don't lose. Menu engineering tells you which dishes to drop: you compare what each dish sells with what it leaves you every time you sell it. Four groups come out, and each one has a clear decision.
There's a temptation we've all had. A customer asks if you've got anything gluten-free, or some fish, or something “lighter”. And next month the menu has three more dishes on it.
And so, without noticing, you get to 45 dishes. And a cold room full of things that go out twice a week.
Why a long menu is costing you money
More stock. Every dish needs its ingredients. The more dishes, the more different things in the cold room, the more money tied up and the more risk of something going out of date.
More waste. The dishes that sell least are the ones that throw away most. The stock gets opened for one portion and the rest waits… until it's no good any more.
More work and more mistakes. More mise en place, more spec sheets to remember, more chance of each dish coming out differently depending on who's on the pass.
Customers who take longer to decide. An endless menu doesn't give freedom, it gives stress. The customer takes longer, asks more questions and often ends up ordering the usual.
A blurred identity. If you do a bit of everything, nobody knows why they should come to your place. And in 2026, with customers choosing more carefully where to spend their money, having a clear concept is one of the things that weighs most.
What menu engineering is
It's a method for analysing the menu with numbers, not with sentiment. Two American professors, Kasavana and Smith, developed it in the eighties, and it's still used because it works.
It compares two figures for each dish:
- Popularity: how many portions you sell compared with the rest.
- Margin: how much each portion leaves you (price without VAT minus the cost from the recipe costing).
And it puts each dish into one of these four groups:
| High margin | Low margin | |
|---|---|---|
| Sells a lot | Star | Plowhorse |
| Sells little | Puzzle | Dog |
How to do it with your menu, step by step
Step 1. Gather a month's data
For each dish in one section (starters, mains, desserts… each section is analysed separately):
- Portions sold in the month. Your till system gives you this.
- Sale price without VAT.
- Cost per portion, from the recipe costing. No costings, no menu engineering. It's that simple.
Step 2. Work out each dish's margin
Notice that we're not looking at food cost as a percentage, but in euros. A dish with a 40% food cost can leave you more euros than one at 25%. And what you pay at the end of the month is euros.
Step 3. Separate the popular dishes from the rest
The method's rule: a dish is popular if it sells more than 70% of what it would get if every dish sold the same.
In practice: divide 100 by the number of dishes and multiply by 0.7. With 6 dishes: 100 ÷ 6 × 0.7 = 11.7% of the section's sales. Anything above that is popular.
Step 4. Separate high margin from low margin
Work out the section's average margin: add up the total margin of all the dishes and divide by the total portions. Anything above it is high margin. Anything below, low margin.
Step 5. Classify and decide
Now every dish is in its box. Time to act.
An example with numbers
A mains section with 6 dishes, in a typical month (an illustrative example, prices without VAT):
| Dish | Portions | Price | Cost | Margin/portion | Total margin |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Homemade croquettes | 400 | €9.00 | €2.20 | €6.80 | €2720 |
| House burger | 350 | €13.00 | €5.50 | €7.50 | €2625 |
| Señorito rice | 180 | €16.00 | €5.60 | €10.40 | €1872 |
| Grilled octopus | 90 | €19.00 | €7.20 | €11.80 | €1062 |
| Seasonal salad | 70 | €10.00 | €3.10 | €6.90 | €483 |
| Lasagne | 60 | €12.00 | €4.60 | €7.40 | €444 |
| Total | 1150 | €9206 |
- Popularity threshold: 11.7% of 1,150 = 134 portions.
- Average margin: €9,206 ÷ 1,150 = €8.00 per portion.
Result:
| Dish | Popular? | High margin? | Group |
|---|---|---|---|
| Señorito rice | Yes (180) | Yes (€10.40) | Star |
| Homemade croquettes | Yes (400) | No (€6.80) | Plowhorse |
| House burger | Yes (350) | No (€7.50) | Plowhorse |
| Grilled octopus | No (90) | Yes (€11.80) | Puzzle |
| Seasonal salad | No (70) | No (€6.90) | Dog |
| Lasagne | No (60) | No (€7.40) | Dog |
Look at the croquettes. They're the dish that sells most. Everyone would say they're the best thing on the menu. And they're the one that leaves least per portion.
What to do with each group
Stars: protect them
They sell and they leave money. Don't touch them, except to look after them.
- Put them in the best spot on the menu (top right, and at the start of each section, is where the eye goes most).
- Have the team recommend them.
- Quality always the same. A star that has an off day loses customers.
Plowhorses: raise their margin without anyone noticing
They sell a lot but leave little. They're the ones that can give you the most money if you adjust them a little, because every cent is multiplied by a lot of portions.
- Adjust the portion or the garnish.
- Check the cost: supplier, waste, recipe.
- Put the price up bit by bit. I explain how in how to raise prices without losing customers.
In the example: if the croquettes go up by 50 cents, that's €200 more a month without selling a single one more.
Puzzles: give them a chance
They leave a good margin, but they don't sell. Often the problem isn't the dish, it's how it's sold.
- Change the name or the description. Make it tempting.
- Move it to a more visible spot on the menu.
- Have the team recommend it: “the octopus is spectacular today”.
- Check the price: it may be above what your customer expects in that section.
If after a couple of months it still isn't selling, it moves to the group below.
Dogs: off the menu
They neither sell nor leave money. All they do is take up cold room, time and space on the menu.
- Drop them. No regrets.
- The exception: if a dish is essential for one type of customer (the only vegetarian option, for example), keep it but improve it so it leaves more.
In the example, the salad and the lasagne come off the menu. Two dishes fewer, two recipes fewer to prep, and all their stock out of the cold room.
How many dishes should my menu have?
There's no magic number; it depends on the concept and the kitchen you have. My reference: a few options per section, which you can make perfectly every day. If your kitchen can't turn out a dish just as well on a Saturday at ten as on a Tuesday at two, that dish is surplus.
And a good sign: if someone reading your menu knows in ten seconds what kind of restaurant you are, you're on the right track.
And what about average spend?
A short, well-worked menu also raises average spend, because:
- It's easier to recommend when the team knows the menu by heart.
- You can suggest starters to share, a wine by the glass that goes with the stars, a house dessert.
- The customer decides quickly and goes for more when they don't have to wrestle with 45 options.
How often to repeat the analysis
- Every quarter, with the data from the till.
- Whenever you change the menu or the cost of an important product goes up.
- Before and after high season, on the coast, because the customers and what they order change.
Do you know which of your dishes are stars and which are dogs? Start with the cost of each portion using the recipe costing template. And if you'd like us to analyse your menu together, let's talk.
Frequently asked questions
What is menu engineering?
It's a method for analysing the menu by comparing each dish's popularity with the margin it leaves. It classifies dishes as stars, plowhorses, puzzles and dogs, and helps you decide what to keep, what to adjust and what to drop.
Do I need recipe costings to do menu engineering?
Yes. Without knowing what each portion costs you, you can't work out the margin, and without margin the analysis is useless.
Is it better to look at food cost or margin in euros?
Margin in euros. The percentage tells you whether a dish is well costed, but what you pay at the end of the month is euros. An expensive dish with a high food cost can leave you more money than a cheap one with a low food cost.
How often do I have to change the menu?
There's no need to change the whole thing often. Check the numbers every quarter, drop the dogs, work on the puzzles and adjust the plowhorses. Two menu changes a year, one for summer and one for winter, are usually enough.